Kumamoto
We are displayed with mode now at large-scale disaster.

Kumamoto art police project Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design open call for participants model proposal

The last update date:
Department of Civil Engineering Architecture Division 
TEL: 096-333-2533 
FAX: 096-384-9820 
Email [email protected]

 

 

 

About judge long comment of proposal public examination (February 20, 2020)

 

Open call for participants type proposal second (publicly) examination pertaining to Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design

Commissioner judge long comment/Kumamoto art police proposal judge long Toyoo Ito

 

 As for the public second examination, it was while many people watched that we were enriched so as to forget time for sincere presentation of various places of 5 teams inferior to neither. Exact model that great energy was bet on was worth seeing, and we could grasp a feeling of scale and structure of the whole site more clearly, and heat entered question.
 Four years pass from evil at 2016 and thank that strong will doing is visible or stands for revival that added new imagination called "creative revival" by governor or younger, effort of all of you and the relations prefectures as thing engaged in building very much. Wooden temporary housing more than 600, more than 100 "houses of all" are built, and we are stouthearted as thing marking line until now, and approach such as reusing as much as possible thinks.
 Earthquake disaster museum core base facility would be made in the foot of Aso on the basis of such a process, and this proposal exhibition examination committee was held. It was thing examination committee, but people of 5 teams had each recite thought for the way of earthquake disaster museum. Venue became competition to compete for rare concept purely with atmosphere that held symposium recently in Japan.
 As a result of having made discussion for suggestion that it was hard to add the superiority and inferiority to in spite of being all the judges, trouble, "o+h, sanko*kei JV" elected "atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community" in award for excellence of second in the highest award.

 

 As for the plan of best "o+h, sanko*kei JV", positioning called one museum in "corridor format" that we connected the whole earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure which lay scattered with network was understood enough, and fantastic thing along the topography was appreciated for magnificent nature peculiar to the foot of Aso that was site. After having seen miserable dislocation that line of it continues and Tokai University Building No. 1 is horrible resulting from earthquake disaster in scenery of beautiful Aso, it is expected as thing which building comprised of this soft curve softens mind, and gives new beautiful scenery. In a sense it was the boldest suggestion, and there was opinion that there were places felt uneasy about such as specifications of exhibition room placement and roof broken up for building. It is that it was chosen in very slight difference by saying to finally bet on freshness just superior to that.

 

 Very stable structure is suggested to plan of "atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community" which became award for excellence, generally of security there came to plan to be. Made use of experience of past earthquake disaster support, and was evaluated, but was not felt that was plan that could expect very at organization and point called administration to make area community around museum the other charm for building by new organization, so for the highest award of some it will be said that fell.


 Suggestion of 3 teams which became fine work was attractive, and it was such confused fight that vote entered to all 5 teams in the first phase of the second examination. We make a comment that announcement is easy sequentially as random order.

 

 There were many structure of roof, opinions that we got balance generally including display format and was asked about plan of "contemporary". Effect to feel that we enter after having seen internal display of "garden of thought" in the circular center in abstract scenery that outside, familiar scenery is different is the first charm.
Evaluation will be divided for some function space sticking out of form itself circular and the outside caught favorably by primary examination.

 

 Plan of "corporation Kumiko Inui architecture drawing office" piled up archive closely, and suggestion that was very intellectual, and was konsepuchuaru to make full use of workshop, and to make museum was appreciated by primary examination. We were targeted for discussion whether you were suitable for site as this was circular plane type. Exchange of opinions was done, but, structure using CLT, "inorinomichi" on roof, it was not tied to the final evaluation for suggestion of "caldera open space".

 

 Plan of "Acis co-op, Schenk Hattori design community" is powerful, of aspect there was expanse, and other plans were suggestion to bring about ground of original requiem to mark line, and there was deep-rooted recommendation opinion in terms of time. It is fresh, and suggestion of structure full of changes was appreciated, but space that can foresee all linearly and recommendation opinion that just overturns opinion that there is a feeling of resistance as display space in the sloping floor will remain in crying fine work.

 

 It means that narrow margin determined very much while discussion is well contested. People who missed the highest award have you challenge again without learning lesson from this and hope that you can contribute to development of further art police eagerly.
 In closing, we express will of thanks to people concerned who had you plan this proposal in various places who applied in various places who arrived.

 

 

 

About the last examination result (February 12, 2020)

 

Results of the public second examination that we carried out in Kumamoto prefectural government office on February 11 (Tuesday Sundays and holidays) are as follows.

 

1. Open call for participants type proposal/examination result

 

                The application registration name

    The location

   (representative)

 The highest award o+h, sanko*kei JV    Tokyo
 Award for excellence Atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community    Tokyo
 Fine work Contemporary    Kanagawa
 Fine work Corporation Kumiko Inui architecture drawing office    Tokyo
 Fine work Acis co-op, Schenk Hattori design community    Tokyo

 ※We publish fine work in rearranging numerical order in application reception desk.

 

(reference) Summary of business 

 The business main constituent: Kumamoto
 Construction place: In Kawayo, Minamiaso-mura, Aso-gun (Tokai University Aso campus)
 Scale: We assume principle wooden construction, 2 stories or less, 1,300 square meters basics
 Contents: Experience, display facility

 

 

2. Technical proposal (style 8)

   Highest award /o+h, sanko*kei JV (PDF: 28.85 megabytes) We open with the other window

   Award for excellence/atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community (PDF: 4.69 megabytes) We open with the other window

   Fine work/contemporary (PDF: 17.16 megabytes) We open with the other window

   Fine work/corporation Kumiko Inui architecture drawing office (PDF: 2.99 megabytes) We open with the other window

   Fine work/Acis co-op, Schenk Hattori design community (PDF: 20.83 megabytes) We open with the other window


  We publish some extracts of technical proposal (style 8) below.

 

 Highest award/o+h, sanko*kei JV
 No10
 

  Award for excellence/atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community
 No26
  Fine work/contemporary

  No3

  Fine work/corporation Kumiko Inui architecture drawing office
  No24

  Fine work/Acis co-op, Schenk Hattori design community
  No30

 

 

 

 

About result of primary examination of the prefecture combination office (January 29, 2020)

 

As the following people would advance to the second examination, we will tell about the prefecture combination office. (as there is little number of the applicants, we do not carry out primary examination.)

 

1. The application situation

 The number of application pertaining to the choice of the prefecture combination office: Two cases

 

2. Primary examination passage person

 

    Rearranging

    Number

                                    The application registration name

       The location

      (representative)

   1 kabushikikaishata**keijimusho Kumamoto-shi
   2 Light design Kumamoto-shi

 ※Reference number is application reception number.


 

 

 

Guidance (January 14, 2020) of public examination (the second examination)

 

About public examination (the second examination) of this proposal, we hold as follows.

We carry out presentation by 5 people who passed primary examination from 41 points who had application from the whole country. We assume Commissioner Toyoo Ito art police the judge head and have a question-and-answer session at open place and choose designer deserving to be most.

As you can see anyone, you have you arrive, and you are, please sense moment when you begin to walk for symbol of restoration, revival from Kumamoto earthquake and embodiment of earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility where it is bodily.

 

<< February 7, 2020 postscript >>

 For coronavirus measures new as for the participation planned person on that day; notice was; hope that bloom.

 Information about new coronavirus measures from this → https://www.pref.kumamoto.jp/kiji_30386.html

 

[holding summary]

(1) The date and time: February 11, 2020 (Tuesday Sundays and holidays) from 10:00 to 15:30 (the opening: at 9:30)

(2) Venue: Kumamoto prefectural government office administration ridge Main Building large meeting room (6-18-1, Suizenji, Chuo-ku, Kumamoto-shi) under the ground

(3) Capacity: 250 (given priority to prior application) ※You can see viewing for free, anyone.

(4) Application method: Apply by viewing application in mail, FAX to the art police secretariat or E-mail.

(5) Contents: 1) The opening of a meeting, sponsor greetings

         2) Publisher presentation and individual interpellation

         3) The whole question

         4) The last examination

         5) Announcement of examination result, judge long comment and commendation

<< flyer >>

   Second examination holding flyer | Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility open call for participants model proposal (PDF: 241.1 kilobytes) We open with the other window

 

<< viewing application >>

   Viewing application | Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility open call for participants model proposal (PDF: 419.5 kilobytes) We open with the other window

   Viewing application | Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility open call for participants model proposal (word: 76 kilobytes) We open with the other window


Public examination flyer | Image


 

 

 

About judge long comment of primary examination (January 9, 2020)

 

Open call for participants type proposal first examination pertaining to Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design

Commissioner judge long comment/Kumamoto art police proposal judge long Toyoo Ito

 

 

 Kumamoto earthquake does hatsuwazawai, and more than three years pass, and topic that step of restoration, revival advances to steadily while receiving domestic and foreign great support seems to penetrate widely.

 In Kumamoto art police, temporary housing, meeting facility "family of all" continue being concerned with disaster public housing plans by hatsuwazawaigo, request of the governor. There is process that came to carry out one and open call for participants type proposal of revival symbol of earthquake disaster museum core base facilities that it is from the field of building on theme called creative revival while we talked with about how you connect with the next step wherever possible.


 41 entries which became the most in the open call for participants type proposal of art police this time gathered and were surprised at height of interest in Kumamoto revival some other time.
 Entry was really full of masterpieces and needed time for the election of 5 plan to pass the first examination. In the first phase of examination, 21 plan was elected as candidate seven judges by vote of five votes of one. We compared good point bad point one by one and, for the second phase, were able to narrow down to 9 plan about plan with a little number of votes in this. We decided to exclude 2 plan from candidate while confirming thought for the way of earthquake disaster museum of each judge for the third phase. In the last phase, we repeated discussions about the remainder 7 plan carefully and decided 5 plans to advance to the second examination unanimously.


 A great many variations were to entry, and pattern classification was difficult, too. In the background, there is proposition to bind earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure, revival base that is various in Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum together in corridor format and thinks that there is the situation entrusted to concrete display contents of each apart from image as the entirety in the future. Particularly, suggestion of applicant seems to have diverged into many branches that it was the core facility. In addition, in addition, elements such as what it is doing pick quarrel with design condition between the fresh wooden construction sky which made good use of Kumamoto product materials, and it may trouble choice of judge surface of the earth seismic dislocation which is earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure and that flexibility has room highly at place where Aso unique rich Vista is provided in the very large site that is next to former Tokai University Aso school building Building No. 1. In the process of examination, opinion to be thing that is indispensable to continuous museum administration remains in impression whether this core facility does neighboring facilities and local various places and what kind of cooperation.
 

 We want to act in selection of the most hot stuff while comparing opinion of 5 people elected with all of the venues by the second examination.
 In closing, many people show interest in this proposal and want to express will of thanks in what we spend great labor and applied for some other time.

 

 

 

About result of primary examination (December 24, 2019)

 

Results of primary examination that we carried out on Monday, December 23, 2019 are as follows.

 

1. The application situation

 The number of open call for participants type proposal application: 41 cases

 

2. Primary examination passage person 

 

    Rearranging

    Number

                                   The application registration name

           The location

        (representative)

     3

 Contemporary

         Kanagawa
    10 o+h, sanko*kei JV          Tokyo
    24 Corporation Kumiko Inui architecture drawing office          Tokyo
    26 Atelier one Kokusai Kaihatsu Consultants design community          Tokyo
    30 Acis co-op, Schenk Hattori design community          Tokyo
 ※Reference number is application reception number.
 
3. Future plan
 The second examination (publicly)
  The date and time: From Tuesday, February 11, 2020 10:00 a.m. 3:30 p.m. (plan)
  Venue: Kumamoto prefectural government office Main Building large meeting room under the ground
  Contents: (1) Publisher presentation
        (2) The whole question
        (3) The last examination
        (4) Announcement of examination result, judge long public announcement and commendation

 

 

 

 

We raise the prefecture combination offices again (from December 19, 2019 to January 22, 2020)

 

When the prefecture authorized architect office is not included in person chosen by this proposal, we decide to cross the prefecture combination office and joint venture (JV).

As after raising the prefecture combination offices on October 4, 2019, there was not application, it recruits the prefecture combination offices again.

 

 ◎Schedule

 Thursday, December 19, 2019            Essential point announcement, application acceptance start (re-offer)
 From Thursday, December 19, 2019 to Wednesday, January 22 essential point distribution
 Wednesday, January 22, 2020               The application deadline
   Monday, January 27, 2020                                   Primary examination (secrecy)
   February 11, 2020 (Tuesday Sundays and holidays)                           The second examination (secrecy)

 

 

Open call for participants type proposal (the choice of the prefecture combination office) application essential points (re-offer)

 

  The choice (re-offer) of the prefecture combination office pertaining to 02-01 application essential point/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design (PDF: 156.1 kilobytes) We open with the other window

    The choice (re-offer) of the prefecture combination office pertaining to 02-02 making point/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design (PDF: 44 kilobytes) We open with the other window

    The choice (re-offer) of the prefecture combination office pertaining to collection of 02-03 styles/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design (Excel: 159.5 kilobytes) We open with the other window

    Open call for participants type proposal (re-offer) pertaining to 03-01 specifications/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design (PDF: 122.1 kilobytes) We open with the other window


 

  

 

Question answer (November 5, 2019) about open call for participants type proposal

 

 Answers to written inquiry which had you submit by October 25, 2019 are as follows.

(attention)

・Plan site is shown in attachment information about specifications 2(1) - (2), but does area of red dashed line of addition material 2 with plus.

・There is mention of facilities pull-in assumption position in attachment information about specifications 2(4), but as a result of having considered again, does contents of addition information 2 with plus.

・As there were some defects in mention of collection of styles as you pointed out even written inquiry, we publish thing which we revised. We would appreciate your using style of publication this time.

 

 

Question answer

 

  04-01 question answer (R1.11.05)/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 248.3 kilobytes) We open with the other window

  04-02 question number 81 (attached 1) (PDF: 198.8 kilobytes) We open with the other window

  04-03 question number 85 (attached 2) (PDF: 362.4 kilobytes) We open with the other window



 

Additional material

 

  Around 04-05 (addition material 2) site figure (neighboring facilities) (PDF: 742.2 kilobytes) We open with the other window

  Of 04-06 (addition material 3) Hinagu dislocation strip off; about specimen (PDF: 2.72 megabytes) We open with the other window

  04-07 (addition material 4) Building No. 1 preservation construction drawing (ground plan, elevation) (PDF: 619.6 kilobytes) We open with the other window


 

 

Collection of styles (revision)

 


 

 

 

 

About supplementary material in local visit society (November 5, 2019)

 

 We publish in reference to data of panel which we used for explanation in local visit society that we held on October 15, 2019.

  Photograph (PDF: 513.5 kilobytes) of 03-02 "local visit society" supplementary material/surface of the earth seismic dislocation We open with the other window

  Photograph (PDF: 211.1 kilobytes) of destruction of 03-03 "local visit society" supplementary material/desk work section room dislocation and pillar We open with the other window

  Visit to 03-04 "local visit society" supplementary material/Building No. 1 passage image figure (PDF: 2.1 megabytes) We open with the other window


 

 

 

 

Question (partly) answer (October 24, 2019) about open call for participants type proposal


 On the submission deadline, November 5 assumed scheduled answer date, but eight questions about "qualifications" are submitted as of October 23, and, about question about this proposal, October 25 judges participation in this proposal about question about "qualifications"; will announce answer beforehand because is important. Answers are as follows.

 

 

Question answer (partly)

 

  04-01 question answer (R1.10.23)/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 58.4 kilobytes) We open with the other window


 

 

 

About questions and answers, supplementary matter in local visit society (October 24, 2019)

 

 We publish questions and answers, supplement information in local visit society that we held on October 15, 2019 and October 16, 2019 as follows.

 

  03-01 "local visit society" questions and answers, supplementary information/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 1.02 megabytes) We open with the other window



 

  •  

    Publication (October 21, 2019) of video of plan site

  •  
  •  As we publish video which we photographed along route which we observed in local visit society that we carried out on October 15 and 16 in 2019,
  •  Person who did not participate in local visit party, please be referred to.
  •  ※ In addition, to individual local visit please note that cannot cope.

 

 

  [picture 1]

  

 [picture 2]

  

 [picture 3]

  

 [picture 4]

  
 


  •  
  • About holding of local visit society (October 4, 2019)

 

 

 

 

  •  

    Held summary of local visit society

    On the date
  • * The first Tuesday, October 15, 2019 (from 14:00 to 15:30)
    * The second Wednesday, October 16, 2019 (from 14:00 to 15:30)

 

  • Meeting place
  • The field, please gather to participant in Tokai University Aso campus.
     (the details refer to visit society flyer)
  • Visit place
    * Dislocation to store as earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure and Building No. 1 (damaged building)
    * Plan site of experience-based display facility and the outskirts

  •  Instructions
    According to essential point mention, we do not accept question in local visit society.
    In addition, we may not accept proposal about this proposal when there is person who caused problems such as entrances without permission any place other than the appointment area.


      

Kumamoto art police project Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design open call for participants model proposal (October 4, 2019)

1. Purpose

  This prefecture pushes forward step toward the cause of much support from home and abroad, revival from earthquake steadily while more than three years pass from evil of Kumamoto earthquake in 2016 when earthquake with a seismic intensity of 7 occurred twice during only 28 hours. For large-scale disaster not to know when and where it takes place, we leave memory and experience, lesson of Kumamoto earthquake in history and will think that it is our duty that experienced Kumamoto earthquake to send to home and abroad widely as well as this prefecture in future.  
 From this, local local bases such as culture, interchange facility leaving trace of Kumamoto earthquake with earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure such as dislocation which appeared in various places throughout the prefecture widely in this prefecture

We tie tourist facilities conveying base of activity for revival to be able to put, local charm regionally and push forward maintenance of Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum as field museum of "corridor format" to rotate.
 As the core base of Aso area in this Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum, it is next to surface of the earth seismic dislocation which is earthquake disaster remains of an ancient structure and old Tokai University Aso school building Building No. 1 and maintains facility having display learning function, education function, interchange function, general counter function. In maintenance, we decide to send various information such as lesson that we got from plain figure and Kumamoto earthquake of damage from symbolic place leaving damage of Kumamoto earthquake, wonder of nature and carry out open call for participants type proposal.

 In addition, we carry out this proposal as participation business of "Kumamoto art police" which Kumamoto promotes for creation of cultural assets left in history and local activation.

 

2. Summary of proposal

(1) Name
Open call for participants type proposal pertaining to Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design 
(2) Method
Open call for participants type proposal 
The prefecture authorized architect office and joint venture which were chosen separately when the prefecture authorized architect office was still less included in person chosen in this proposal
We assume that we cross trust requirements of basic design duties and perform open call for participants of the prefecture authorized architect office concerned at the same time.
(3) Sponsorship
Kumamoto 
(4) The secretariat
The Kumamoto art police secretariat (Kumamoto Department of Civil Engineering architecture Housing Bureau Architecture Division) 
(5) Schedule
Friday, October 4, 2019
Essential point announcement, application acceptance start
From Friday, October 4, 2019 to Wednesday, December 11
Essential point distribution
From Friday, October 4, 2019 to Friday, October 25
Question reception desk
Tuesday, October 15, 2019, Wednesday, October 16, 2019
Local visit society
Tuesday, November 5, 2019 (plan)
Question answer
Wednesday, December 11, 2019
The application deadline
Monday, December 23, 2019
Primary examination (secrecy)
February 11, 2020 (Tuesday Sundays and holidays) (plan)
The second examination (publicly)
※When the prefecture authorized architect office is not included in chosen person, we carry out selection of the prefecture authorized architect office making joint venture by secrecy after the second examination.
 

3. Judge

The judge head
Toyoo Ito (architect, Commissioner Kumamoto art police)
Judge
Hideaki Katsura (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police)
Kaori Suehiro (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police, Associate Professor at Kyushu University)
Masashi Sogabe (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police, Kanagawa University's professor)

Shinichiro Ikebe (curator, Aso Geopark promotion meeting secretary general, Aso Volcanic Museum's director)
Ryuji Kakimoto (the way examination well-informed person meeting chairperson of Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum, Manager of Kumamoto University Kumamoto water cycle, genwazawaikenkyukyoiku center, Kumamoto University Graduate School professor)
Akihiro Harayama (kumahonkenchijikoshitsumatsurigotosakushingikan)


 

4. Information materials

Open call for participants type proposal application essential points

 

Open call for participants type proposal (the choice of the prefecture combination office) application essential points

     

   The choice (PDF: 44 kilobytes) of the prefecture combination office pertaining to 02-02 making point/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design We open with the other window

     The choice (Excel: 172 kilobytes) of the prefecture combination office pertaining to collection of 02-03 styles/Kumamoto earthquake earthquake disaster museum core base facility maintenance basic design We open with the other window


 

Specifications 

 

Even Kumamoto art police Facebook, Instagram, Twitter send information.

Access from this! ⇒https://www.facebook.com/kumamotoartpolis/ (Facebook)

            https://www.instagram.com/kumamotoartpolis/ (Instagram)

            https://twitter.com/kumamoto_kap (Twitter)

 

 

 

We relate to this page
Inquiry

Department of Civil Engineering Architecture Division art police, UD group
Telephone: 096-333-2537
(ID: 28571)
※When PDF file is attached as materials, Adobe Acrobat(R) is necessary.
When you look at PDF documents, Adobe Reader is necessary. When you are not displayed definitely, please use the latest version.
Kumamoto prefectural government office   〒 862-8570  6-18-1, Suizenji, Chuo-ku, Kumamoto-shi, Kumamoto Tel: 096-383-1111 (main)
Copyright(C) 2015 Kumamoto Prefectural Government. All rights reserved.