- We published prize winner comment on July 10, 2020.
- We announced the last examination result on May 15, 2020.
About held postponement of examination open on February 26, 2020
- We announced judge long comment of primary examination on February 10, 2020。
- We published held guidance of public examination (the second examination) on February 6, 2020.
- We announced result of primary examination on January 31, 2020.
- We published question answer on November 29, 2019.
- We published question (partly) answer on November 14, 2019.
- We announced summary of local visit society on October 29, 2019.
- We published application essential points on October 29, 2019.
About prize winner comment (July 10, 2020)
We publish prize winner comment of highest award "Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa".
Prize winner comment
Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa Jiro Ogawa
Thank you very much for electing in the highest award. From announcement of proposal to announcement of the last examination result, it was prolonged approach to need about half a year. Of done judge who is still effort for the Komeito, fair examination taking the purpose of Kumamoto art police project into consideration in the unprecedented situation called corona crisis want to express feeling of gratitude as designer deeply again in various places in various places of Kumamoto.About the last examination result (May 15, 2020)
Theme to work really, and to be worth "demanding new wooden space by this proposal beautifully" was raised. In late years, as for the proposal that professed itself to be possibility of building such briefly and powerfully, there are none in memory. In process of design, we tried to converge for plan for one point. If our suggestion was able to get closer to such a high ideal even a little, it may be said that it is right unexpected joy. We want to repeat efforts in future to realize suggestion in best state.
1. The last examination result
| || The application registration name|
| The highest award|| Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa|
| Award for excellence|| Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design joint venture|
| Fine work|| Joint company white Kawazai building drawing office|
| Fine work|| Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office|
| Fine work|| Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office|
※We publish fine work in rearranging numerical order in application reception desk.
2. Judge long comment
Commissioner judge long/Kumamoto art police Toyoo Ito
Judge attends by this proposal first examination and was able to examine, but, with nationwide infection spread of unexpected new coronavirus infectious disease, will perform the second examination in remote examination format.
5 people were chosen among 44 entries by primary examination. Remote examination format that we brought chosen people into was one of the assumptions, but discussed with remote after questions and answers by email because we could examine conventional exhibition and became after standing on trouble evasion by fairness and unaccustomedness of WEB environment, and having had you submit presentation video for less than ten minutes and model, CG video for less than two minutes.
Even comment of primary examination spoke that all entries had very a variety of suggestion, but we have you suggest, in particular, original structure and space to 5 plans that remained for the second examination and feel that it was proposal interesting at all.
As for the examination result, "Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office" decided to elect person of "Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office" of 3 in fine work (random order) "joint company white Kawazai building drawing office" award for excellence "Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design community" highest award "Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa".
Suggestion of "Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa" of the highest award was suggestion of hierarchy structure that we had not seen so far. There was opinion to turn in scale of project from judge in meaning to try reciprocal exchange structure to be comprised of elementary and junior high school section materials. There were the most elements which were squirrel key, but, during 5 plans, it was shared in all the judges that it was suggestion with overwhelming originality. The number of problems in construction that must be settled is how many, or stay, but visitor comes over widely in occasion when came true; is novel; when is built, is convinced.
If form of gabled roof which had big eaves with arch truss structure to be comprised of the public distribution materials of small section was stable as for the suggestion of "Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design community" of award for excellence that became the next seat regrettably very beautifully, we were judged. On the other hand, it will be said that we finally fell behind top flight plan that the stability lacks originality in reason. We were impressed by presentation that overflowed for young energy. We pray for second challenge eagerly.
Suggestion of "joint company white Kawazai building drawing office" was very unique for wooden construction. We build big trass beam from every direction and thereby make divided space in integral space. However, we feel like lacking persuasive power of dividing into four a little. Opinion for fear of bend by secular variation was heard in central part. Some said that we evaluated sincere examination such as rationality of work such as agonizing reappraisal or means around the site.
As for the suggestion of "Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office", environmental beauty that adopted outside light by general louver is attractive. The deep appearance was simple, and eaves were good impressions, but the issue of heat of roof of polycarbonate and movement of shadow by louver were not able to overturn opinion to have possibilities to obstacle to work environment.
As for the suggestion of "Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office", there were many opinions that idea of strip of paper board that roof constitution made with workshop interestingly was good of protrusion entablature format that succeeded to traditional wooden construction. However, opinion of question that silhouette might not be familiar with neighboring sceneries including anxiety such as maintenance for supporting big plane with flat roof, a feeling of resistance, the night of polycarbonate outer wall exceeded and unfortunately remained in fine work.
In spite of change of examination method, we have presentation video do suggestion that is individual for 5 people clearly and, also, thank labor to have you meet question by email, and to be piled up. We would appreciate your understanding that we couldn't but examine in such a form.
We had powerful comment to expect suggestion bold most as art police project from representative of Kuhara that accepted "Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa" chosen as the best plan as one of the judges and had spirit to be connected in the future. We think whether there will be various hurdles before completion, but ask as client, builder.
In closing, by the kindness of 5 people, we release presentation video and model video for examination. As applicant, we would appreciate your thinking in conjunction with result that we showed in comment as participant of public examination.
3. About process of the second examination
We planned public examination at first on Tuesday, March 3, 2020, but we changed as follows and, from the viewpoint of prevention of infection spread of new coronavirus infectious disease, carried out.
1) Publisher submits announcement video, model video
2) Judge examines with video, and question book is sent to publisher
3) Publisher submits answer for question
4) Judge carries out this examination by online meeting on the basis of answer
4. About exhibition of the second examination material (announcement video, model video)
We will open the second examination material to the public as in comment of the judge head. We would appreciate your thinking as participant of not only applicant but also public examination.
[highest award/announcement video/Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa]
[highest award/model video/Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa]
[award for excellence/announcement video/Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design joint venture]
[award for excellence/model video/Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design joint venture]
[fine work/announcement video/combination company white Kawazai building drawing office]
[fine work/model video/combination company white Kawazai building drawing office]
[fine work/announcement video/Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office]
[fine work/model video/Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office]
[fine work/announcement video/Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office]
[fine work/model video/Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office]
5. About exhibition of the second examination material (question answer)
6. About exhibition of the second examination material (technique proposal, style 8)
We publish a part of Perth, the model photograph below.
[highest award/Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa]
[award for excellence/Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design joint venture]
[fine work/combination company white Kawazai building drawing office]
[fine work/Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office]
[fine work/Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office]
About held postponement of public examination (February 26, 2020)
Infected person of new coronavirus infectious disease decides to postpone holding from the viewpoint of prevention of infection spread based on even this prefecture having been confirmed about scheduled "public examination of open call for participants type proposal pertaining to ever field wood processing ground new design" on Tuesday, March 3, 2020.
At present, you are undecided, but please understand holding schedule and held method as you tell after the decision some other time on our homepages.
About judge long comment of primary examination (February 10, 2020)
Open call for participants type proposal first examination pertaining to ever field wood processing ground new design
Commissioner judge long comment/Kumamoto art police proposal judge long Toyoo Ito
Being a few private projects and engineering firm which is builder are corporations in Kumamoto art police (KAP), and this project is very unique at points such as aiming at construction while repeating talks. Because in late years fresh wooden architecture utilizing regional distribution wood which we laid emphasis on was theme in KAP, much interest was sent from the whole country. Application products of 44 gather to prove this and are surprised.
Examination was carried out by method to narrow down by vote and discussion of five judges. Because 2 plan was settled idea of 16 earlier in 11 plan, the third phase in the second phase in the first phase of examination, we were narrowed down to 7 plan. We talked with about carefully to elect the remainder 3 plan in the for the last time fourth phase, and it was unanimous, and 5 plans to advance to the second examination were decided.
Called fresh space where *kei*joken has a maximum of 16m in height or less, span of around 20m in wood processing ground having plane of 20m around *30m was simple. However, a variety of plane formats and suggestion of original form with that existed including circles as well as rectangular planes such as square, rectangle. In the rich wooden construction space produced by suggestion of novel construction which became main, there were a lot of things which were considered for lighting and the ventilation.
As business owner making a specialty of wooden construction was one of the judges, in process of examination, we add that it swelled by concrete topics such as wood junction, construction method, material, cost.
This project aims at further activation of wooden construction architecture industry to become driving force of the rebuilding of house at the time of disaster, and expectation is doing that we can compare presentation of various places of person of 5 with leading figure of next-generation wooden construction architecture with in front at place of the second exhibition examination while taking that it is facility which is utilized for upbringing of carpenter that it is, the training for improvement of technology into consideration.
Finally we express will of thanks in spending many people having had this proposal show interest, serious energy, and having applied some other time.
Guidance (February 6, 2020) of public examination (the second examination)
About public examination (the second examination) of this proposal, we hold as follows.
We carry out presentation by 5 people who passed primary examination from 44 points who had application from the whole country. We assume Commissioner Toyoo Ito art police the judge head and have a question-and-answer session at open place and choose designer deserving to be most.
As you can see anyone, you are, please sense moment when unprecedented wood processing ground to have you arrive, and to have beautiful tree housing utilizing distribution wood from Kumamoto begins to walk for embodiment bodily.
(1) The date and time: From Tuesday, March 3, 2020 12:30 to 17:30 (the opening: at 12:00)
(2) Venue: Kumamoto prefectural government office administration ridge Main Building large meeting room (6-18-1, Suizenji, Chuo-ku, Kumamoto-shi) under the ground
(3) Capacity: 250 (given priority to prior application) ※You can see viewing for free, anyone.
(4) Application method: Apply by viewing application in mail, FAX to the art police secretariat or E-mail.
(5) Contents: 1) The opening of a meeting, sponsor greetings
2) Publisher presentation
3) The whole question
4) The last examination
5) Announcement of examination result, judge long comment and commendation
<< flyer >>
Second examination holding flyer | Ever field wood processing ground open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 334.6 kilobytes)
<< viewing application >>
Viewing application | Ever field wood processing ground open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 418.9 kilobytes)
Viewing application | Ever field wood processing ground open call for participants type proposal (word: 75.5 kilobytes)
About result of primary examination (January 31, 2020)
Results of primary examination that we carried out on Thursday, January 30, 2020 are as follows.
1. The application situation
The number of open call for participants type proposal application: 44 cases
2. Primary examination passage person
| The application registration name|
| Kurakake, Akiyama, Inoue, Kawasaki architecture design joint venture|| Fukuoka|
| Joint company white Kawazai building drawing office|| Aichi|
| 7|| Jiro Ogawa/atelier shimusa +kaa|| Tokyo|
| 13|| Tetsuya Mizukami architecture drawing office first class authorized architect office|| Chiba|
| 35|| Takanari Yamashita architecture drawing office || Tokyo|
※Reference number is application reception number.
3. Future plan
The second examination (publicly)
The date and time: From Tuesday, March 3, 2020 0:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. (plan)
Venue: Kumamoto prefectural government office administration ridge Main Building large meeting room under the ground
Contents: (1) Publisher presentation
(2) The whole question
(3) The last examination
(4) Announcement of examination result, judge long public announcement and commendation
Question answer (November 29, 2019) about open call for participants type proposal
Answers to written inquiry which had you submit by November 22, 2019 are as follows.
03-01 question answer (R1.11.29)/ever field wood processing ground open call for participants type proposal (PDF: 400 kilobytes)
Guide (PDF: 4.5 megabytes) of the wooden building spread with 03-02 (addition material 1) Kumamoto wood from prefecture
03-03 (addition material 2) site CAD data (file: 97.9 kilobytes)
Figure of 03-04 (addition material 3) land utility plan (PDF: 132.3 kilobytes)
Question (partly) answer (November 14, 2019) about open call for participants type proposal
On the submission deadline, November 29 assumes scheduled answer date, but four questions about "qualifications" are submitted as of November 13, and, about question about this proposal, November 22 will announce answer beforehand. Answers are as follows.
Question (partly) answer
- About holding of local visit society (October 29, 2019)
- Please submit visit society application to the secretariat beforehand if you would like to participate as we hold local visit party as follows.
- Until return day Monday, November 11, 2019 3:00 p.m. of application
Open call for participants type proposal (Excel: 41 kilobytes) pertaining to visit society application/ever field wood processing ground new design Visit to spot society | Guidance flyer (PDF: 847 kilobytes)
Held summary of local visit societyOn the date
- * The first Tuesday, November 12, 2019 (from 13:00 to 16:00)
* The second Wednesday, November 13, 2019 (from 13:00 to 16:00)
- Meeting place, visit place
- Oaza, Kosa-machi, Kamimashiki-gun, Kumamoto prefecture territory character Shimohara 892 (the maintenance planned site)
(the details refer to visit society flyer)
- ※Please park car in the maintenance planned site.
Kumamoto art police project ever field wood processing ground new construction design open call for participants model proposal (October 29, 2019)
- Visit method
Come over to the field at any time between from 13:00 to 16:00 and do with method to have you observe respectively.
In street described in essential point, local visit society, we do not accept question about proposal.
In addition, about person who caused problems such as entrance to any place other than the appointment area without permission, on-the-street parking to neighboring roads, we may not accept proposal about this proposal.
In the case of Kumamoto earthquake that occurred in 2016, ever Field was engaged in construction of many temporary housing complexes, and 211 wooden construction temporary housing and 13 wooden construction meeting facilities built "house of all". In addition, we are engaged in new approach called construction of "Kumamoto model revival house" in consideration for quake resistance and cost reduction and wooden construction disaster public housing construction by purchase method with engineering firm to support the house rebuilding of victim and are worked on restoration, revival from Kumamoto earthquake, the rebuilding of house of various places suffered from as local engineering firm.
Based on such an experience, we aim at further activation of wooden construction architecture industry to become driving force of the rebuilding of house at the time of disaster, and maintenance of wood processing ground is planned as facility which we can utilize for upbringing of carpenter who is leading figure of wooden construction architecture, the training for improvement of technology.
In maintenance of this wood processing ground, we have you approve of idea of "Kumamoto art police" aiming at regional activation by creation of cultural assets which can remain in history, and housing itself using regional distribution wood carries out open call for participants type proposal as Kumamoto art police project towards beautiful new wooden construction space.
2. Summary of proposal
- (1) Name
- Open call for participants type proposal pertaining to ever field wood processing ground new design
- (2) Method
- Open call for participants type proposal
- (3) Sponsorship
- (4) The secretariat
- The Kumamoto art police secretariat (Kumamoto Department of Civil Engineering architecture Housing Bureau Architecture Division)
- (5) Schedule
- Tuesday, October 29, 2019
- Essential point announcement, application acceptance start
- From Tuesday, October 29, 2019 to Wednesday, January 15, 2020
- Essential point distribution
- From Tuesday, October 29, 2019 to Friday, November 22
- Question reception desk
- Tuesday, November 12, 2019, Wednesday, November 13, 2019
- Local visit society
- Friday, November 29, 2019 (plan)
- Question answer
- Wednesday, January 15, 2020
- The application deadline
- Thursday, January 30, 2020
- Primary examination (secrecy)
- Tuesday, March 3, 2020 (plan)
- The second examination (publicly)
- The judge head
- Toyoo Ito (architect, Commissioner Kumamoto art police)
- Eiji Kuhara (Representative Director ever Field)
- Hideaki Katsura (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police)
- Kaori Suehiro (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police, Associate Professor at Kyushu University)
- Masashi Sogabe (architect, adviser at Kumamoto art police, Kanagawa University's professor)
4. Information materials
Open call for participants type proposal application essential points
Even Kumamoto art police Facebook, Instagram, Twitter send information.
Access from this! ⇒https://www.facebook.com/kumamotoartpolis/ (Facebook)